Are Books Dying? What the "Post-Literate Society" Means for the Way You Think

A recent essay in Nature asks a serious question: could the decline of book reading mark the end of rational thinking? The essay reviews journalist James Marriott’s book The New Dark Ages: The End of Reading and the Dawn of a Post-Literate Society, which argues that sustained reading helped build modern science, democracy, and reason, and that those habits are now at risk.
It’s a bold argument. It is also worth examining carefully. The question is not simply whether people still buy books or can read words on a screen. It is whether we are making time for the kind of attention that lets us follow complex ideas, consider unfamiliar perspectives, and form judgments for ourselves.
What does “post-literate” mean?
“Post-literate” does not mean a society where nobody can read. It describes a culture in which reading (especially long, demanding reading) loses ground to faster, more fragmented forms of media.
Marriott calls this shift the “Great Simplification.” He points to shorter, less complex prose and to readers who may find it harder to stay with difficult material. The smartphone, in his account, made distraction constant and personal: a book has to compete with messages, notifications, news feeds, and videos available at any moment.
The evidence deserves context. Nature reports that sales of popular-science books in the United Kingdom rose to more than five million in 2019, then fell to 2.9 million by 2024-a drop of about 42% from that peak. But the number of popular-science titles sold in 2024 was spread across roughly 20,000 books, several times the number reported for 2000. That suggests a change in the market, not the disappearance of curiosity.
Likewise, one often-cited example about students struggling with the opening of Dickens’s Bleak House came from a 2015 study of 85 English-literature students at two colleges in Kansas. It may prompt useful questions about reading education, but it cannot stand as proof that an entire generation has lost the ability to read difficult writing. As reviewer Anthony Gottlieb notes in Literary Review, broad claims about reading need to be checked against the limits of the evidence.

Reading is more than taking in information
The most persuasive part of the argument is not that books are the only valuable medium. It is that reading asks us to do a particular kind of mental work.
A book does not deliver every idea in a quick visual burst. It asks us to follow sentences, hold details in memory, notice connections, and sometimes reread a paragraph before moving on. A novel may also keep us close to a character’s private thoughts and changing motives for hours. That is different from seeing a person from the outside. Reading gives us time to imagine what it might feel like to interpret the world from someone else’s point of view.
This does not mean film, television, or games cannot be thoughtful or moving. They can. But books remain an unusually direct way to spend time inside another person’s thoughts. Even an airport thriller asks us to follow a chain of events and make sense of what characters know, want, or misunderstand.
Difficulty matters, too. When a challenging book makes us pause, that pause is not necessarily a sign that we should give up. It can be the work itself: testing a first impression, looking for clues, and tolerating uncertainty before deciding what a passage means. These habits are useful beyond reading. They support critical thinking, careful interpretation, and the patience to consider evidence that does not fit an easy answer.

Are phones the whole story?
Marriott’s focus on smartphones is understandable. A device that offers constant interruptions can make sustained attention more difficult. But the claim that smartphones alone are causing weaker reading or less rational public debate is not settled.
As the reviews in The Guardian and Literary Review point out, reading habits are shaped by more than one technology. Television changed how people spent their leisure time long before smartphones became widespread. Access to books, school experiences, family responsibilities, and inequality also influence who has the time and support to read.
There are studies that add to the concern, but they do not prove a simple cause and effect. One analysis of language in books found a shift over recent decades in the balance between reasoning-related and emotion-related terms. That is an interesting cultural pattern; it does not show, on its own, that declining book reading caused a decline in rational thought.
So it is better to treat “post-literate society” as a warning and a lens, not a verdict. It invites us to ask what we may lose when fewer people regularly spend time with complex writing. It does not establish that books are vanishing, that screens make people incapable of reason, or that any single trend explains changes in public debate.
What deep reading gives a reader
Deep reading is not a badge of intelligence, and choosing a book does not automatically make someone more thoughtful. Its value lies in the practice: paying attention long enough to meet an idea on its own terms.
That practice helps us ask better questions. What is the author claiming? What evidence supports the claim? What is assumed but not said? How might another reader interpret the same passage? These are the questions at the heart of deep reading analysis, interpretive writing, and strong critical thinking essays. They are also useful when we encounter a confident opinion online and want to decide whether it deserves our trust.
Reading can also make room for philosophical perspectives that do not arrive with immediate answers. Some books unsettle our assumptions or leave important questions unresolved. That discomfort can be productive. It reminds us that thoughtful judgment is not always quick, and that changing our minds can be part of learning.
A related example is This Ain’t Eden, an interpretive work by Robert H Fox that brings biblical reading, history, folklore, and current scientific knowledge into conversation with a clearly identified metaphysical hypothesis. It is the kind of book that asks readers to consider how evidence, interpretation, and belief relate, rather than treating an interpretation as established scientific fact.

Three habits that make room for reading
You do not need to read for hours every day to protect your attention. A few deliberate habits can help:
- Choose a book that asks something of you. Try one challenging book this quarter. Take your time, look up unfamiliar ideas, and let yourself reread.
- Write a little about what you read. A few notes or paragraphs can turn a first reaction into a considered interpretation. Ask what persuaded you, what you questioned, and what remains unclear.
- Give reading its own time. Put your phone out of reach or silence notifications for a short stretch. Even 20 focused minutes can feel different from reading in the gaps between alerts.
The written word is not dead
Books are not the only route to knowledge, and no single sales figure can tell us whether a society is thinking well. But the practice of reading slowly and attentively is worth preserving. It gives us time to follow an idea, inhabit another point of view, and resist the pressure to reach an instant conclusion.
The real question may not be whether books are dying. It may be whether we will keep choosing the kind of attention that books make possible.